Plain reader index · Human reader page · TXT · Markdown · Raw JSON

T223 PNC - The Tzaddik's Requests Are Not Always Fulfilled — A Deep Kindness

בקשת הצדיק לא תמיד מתמלאת — חסד עמוק

Segment 1

Beginner (EN)

When the tzaddik needs to make a request from Hashem, it can happen that the request is not fulfilled. Sometimes Hashem hears and answers; sometimes He does not. Why would Hashem deny the tzaddik? Rebbe Nachman suggests this is itself a hidden kindness — if the tzaddik's every request were automatically granted, the tzaddik's prayers would feel mechanical and obligatory. The uncertainty keeps the tzaddik in a posture of genuine supplication, real vulnerability, authentic prayer. The element of "sometimes fulfilled and sometimes not" preserves the authenticity of the tzaddik's spiritual relationship with Hashem.

Intermediate (HE)

בקשת הצדיק לא תמיד מתמלאת — "לפעמים שומע ולפעמים לאו". זהו תכנון אלוקי לשמירת אמיתות תפילת הצדיק.

Intermediate (EN)

T223: The tzaddik's requests to Hashem are not always fulfilled — "sometimes heard and sometimes not." This is a divine design to preserve the genuineness of the tzaddik's tefilah (prayer) — uncertainty maintains authentic supplication. LM 223.

Scholarly (HE)

LM א׳ רכג׳ — "כשצריך הצדיק לבקש מה׳... לפעמים שומע ולפעמים לאו"; הספק שומר על אמיתות תפילת הצדיק.