Plain reader index · Human reader page · TXT · Markdown · Raw JSON

T16 (Tinyana) PNC - Madua K'sheAdam Mevakesh Parnasah (Why When a Person Seeks Livelihood)

מדוע כשאדם מבקש פרנסה

Segment 1

Beginner (EN)

They asked: why, when a person seeks parnasah, is it not given to him prepared and set from heaven, but instead through causes — each according to his cause: this one needs to sow grain, plough, and reap; this one needs to travel; this one needs to trade. Why must HaShem clothe parnasah in labor? The answer: the labor is itself the human contribution to a divine kindness, and that contribution is precisely what makes the parnasah his own.

Intermediate (EN)

מדוע הפרנסה אינה ניתנת מן השמים מוכנה, אלא ע"י סיבות — כל אחד לפי סיבתו? *Resolution*: the labor is the human investiture; without labor, the parnasah would not become 'his own' — it is the work that converts gift to earnings.

Scholarly (HE)

ל"מ ח"ב סי' ט"ז; ב"ר א'; ל"מ ח"א סי' נ"ד